Burn the Deck
John Brunswick

How Storytellers Win When Everyone Else Sounds the Same

Discovery in the Age of AI

How AI Killed the Old Playbook and What to Do Instead

4 m read
Hot Take
Key Takeaway

TL;DR

That buyer you just called? They answered your questions to ChatGPT three days ago. Every generic question screams: I didn't bother to learn anything about you. Replace basic questions with ones that prove you invested time. Show up prepared, move past the basics, and jump straight to how you can help. The sellers who win aren't the ones with the best pitch. They're the ones so prepared the buyer thinks: Finally, someone who gets it.

The Scene That Plays Out Every Day

Picture this. A seller hops on a discovery call with a new prospect. They open their notebook, pull up their 20-question checklist, and start from the top:

"So, tell me about your company."

"What challenges are you facing?"

"What does your current process look like?"

The buyer sighs. Responses are short. The meeting ends with a polite "we'll be in touch."

Here's what actually happened: that buyer spent 45 minutes answering questions they already answered to ChatGPT three days ago. Questions the seller could have answered themselves with 15 minutes of research. Questions that screamed: I didn't bother to learn anything about you before this call.

The buyer hung up thinking one thing: This person has nothing to offer me.

What Changed & Why It Matters

Five years ago, sellers controlled the information. Buyers needed you to explain how things worked. They relied on your demos, your case studies, your comparisons. Discovery calls existed because they allowed sellers to create enough pain to drive action through problem identification and urgency creation. It was about the seller's agenda, not the buyer's needs.

That world is gone. What used to take months now takes hours, sometimes minutes.

Think about what this means. Before your first call, your buyer has probably:

Asked ChatGPT to compare you to your top three competitors. Read your G2 reviews. Watched your product videos. Built their own evaluation criteria. Drafted questions specifically to test whether you're worth their time.

They arrive at your meeting in late evaluation mode. You show up with your "101 briefing." No wonder deals stall.

The Old Way vs. The New Way

Let's make this concrete. Here's what basic discovery looks like versus what buyer-focused discovery looks like:

Old Way - Seller Focused

What You Ask

Tell me about your company.

What the Buyer Feels

I didn't Google you.

Sources

None

What You Ask

What are your biggest challenges?

What the Buyer Feels

I have no idea what your industry struggles with.

Sources

None

New Way - Buyer Focused

What You Ask

I saw you're expanding into three new markets this year. I imagine that might be stretching your team's capacity significantly. How does that land with you?

What the Buyer Feels

This person actually researched us.

What You Ask

Based on what we've seen with similar companies, I'd hypothesize you might be experiencing X. Does that resonate?

What the Buyer Feels

They understand our world.

What You Ask

I believe you're using [competitor tool]. We've heard some companies struggle with [specific issue]. How does that match your experience?

What the Buyer Feels

They're not afraid of honest conversation.

What You Ask

What would success look like for you personally in this project?

What the Buyer Feels

They care about me, not just my company.

What You Ask

What have you already learned about solutions like ours?

What the Buyer Feels

They respect the work I've already done.

Why "Know Your Buyer" Changes Everything

Here's the secret: the best discovery happens before the call ever starts.

The book dedicates an entire chapter to this called "Know Your Buyer." The idea is simple but powerful: when you deeply research your audience before you meet them, you show up as someone worth talking to.

Think of it as five layers of homework:

1

Ecosystem Trends

What's happening in their industry? What forces are shaping their market? If you sell to healthcare companies, do you know about the regulatory changes keeping executives up at night? If you sell to retail, do you understand the supply chain pressures they face?

2

Company Strategy

What did their CEO say in the last earnings call? What's on their "About Us" page? What did their recent press releases announce? A 15-minute search can tell you their priorities, their growth plans, their challenges.

3

Business Unit & Team Objectives

Who specifically are you meeting with? What does their department care about? A VP of Operations cares about efficiency and cost. A VP of Customer Success cares about retention and satisfaction. Same company, different worlds.

4

Individual Backgrounds

What's this person's LinkedIn story? Did they just get promoted? Did they come from a competitor? Have they written any posts about their priorities? People love when you notice them.

5

Social Proof That Fits

Do you have customers in their industry? Similar use cases? Relevant results? Showing up with proof that matters to them specifically beats generic case studies every time.

The Payoff: You Become Worth Talking To

Here's what happens when you do this homework:

Your credibility skyrockets

When you reference their specific situation, they think: "This person gets it." That trust is hard to earn and easy to lose. Starting prepared is starting ahead.

You move past the basics

Nobody wants to spend 30 minutes giving you background you could have found yourself. When you show up with a prepared mind and hypothesis, you can move past basic questions to substantive dialogue that validates and builds on your point of view.

You become memorable

Most sellers ask the same generic questions. You stand out simply by proving you cared enough to prepare.

Workbook: The Pre-Call Audit

Before your next discovery call, run each question through this filter to ensure you are asking buyer-focused questions:

Ask Yourself

1

Could the buyer answer my question with a 5-second Google search?

If no:

Rephrase as a hypothesis that proves you researched them

2

Does this question prove I did my homework, or expose that I did not?

If no:

Add specific context from their company, industry, or role

3

Am I asking for my benefit or for theirs?

If no:

Reframe to validate or expand on what they already know

4

Would I be annoyed if someone asked me this question?

If no:

Transform it into an insight they have not considered

5

Have I asked what they have already learned about solutions like ours?

If no:

Respect their AI research and build on it

6

Do I have a hypothesis to test rather than a blank slate to fill?

If no:

Prepare a point of view based on similar companies

The Bottom Line

Discovery is not dead, it has evolved. The old discovery was about learning from buyers. The new discovery is about proving you already understand their world. Buyers do not need you to educate them on your product because they have already done that research. What they need is someone who can validate what they have learned, fill the gaps AI could not, help them think through their specific situation, and make them look smart to their boss.

The sellers who win are not the ones with the best pitch. They are the ones who show up so prepared that the buyer thinks: Finally, someone who gets it. That starts before the call with building meaning for your buyer. Research gives you credibility, and the next phase shows you how to translate that credibility into trust, the currency that actually closes deals.

Next
An Experience Worth Sharing